Application prospect and ethical risk of human organoids research
LUO Huiyu1, MA Yonghui2
1. School of Marxism, Xinxiang Medical University, Xinxiang 453003, China;
2. Centre for Bioethics, Medical College, Xiamen University, Xiamen 361102, China
Abstract：The use of human organoids is a breakthrough with respect to the animal models in biomedical research and is a new alternative platform for the translational medicine by combining the emerging technologies such as the gene editing and the organ chip. Human organoids have broad application prospects in establishing disease models, screening drugs, organ transplantation, gene therapy and precision medicine. However, while the whole innovation cycle of the biomedical research is greatly shortened, the use of human organoids also blurs the traditional boundaries between subject and object, public and private, research and treatment, which will cause many ethical and legal challenges. This paper reviews the research progress and the application prospect of human organoids, including a systematic discussion of the main ethical issues such as the moral status of organoids, the informed consent, the commercialization and the benefit sharing. It is concluded that a multi-dimensional governance strategy is needed to guide a healthy and sustainable development of studies of organoids.
[1] Li M, Izpisua Belmonte J C.Organoids-preclinical models of human disease[J].The New England Journal of Medicine, 2019, 380(6):569-579.
[2] Bredenoord A L, Clevers H, Knoblich J A.Human tissues in a dish:The research and ethical implications of organoid technology[J].Science, 2017, 355(6322):eaaf9414.
[3] 董研博,王健,郑梦竹,等.类器官研究进展及应用[J].中国药理学与毒理学杂志, 2019, 33(2):152-160.
[4] Grens K.2013's big advances in science[J/OL].(2013-12-26)[2022-01-12].https://www.the-scientist.com/research-round-up/2013s-big-advances-in-science-38220.
[5] Method of the year 2017:Organoids[J].Nature Methods, 2018, 15(1):1.
[6] Hostiuc S, Rusu M C, Negoi I, et al.The moral status of cerebral organoids[J].Regenerative Therapy, 2019, 10:118-122.
[7] Mollaki V.Ethical challenges in organoid use[J].BioTech, 2021, 10(3):12.
[8] Boers S N, van Delden J J, Clevers H, et al.Organoid biobanking:Identifying the ethics:Organoids revive old and raise new ethical challenges for basic research and therapeutic use[J].EMBO Reports, 2016, 17(7):938-941.
[9] Schork N J.Personalized medicine:Time for one-person trials[J].Nature, 2015, 520(7549):609-611.
[10] Bartfeld S, Clevers H.Stem cell-derived organoids and their application for medical research and patient treatment[J].Journal of Molecular Medicine, 2017, 95(7):729-738.
[11] Choudhury D, Ashok A, Naing M W.Commercialization of organoids[J].Trends in Molecular Medicine, 2020, 26(3):245-249.
[12] Dekkers J F, Wiegerinck C L, de Jonge H R, et al.A functional CFTR assay using primary cystic fibrosis intestinal organoids[J].Nature Medicine, 2013, 19(7):939-945.
[13] Xia Y, Nivet E, Sancho-Martinez I, et al.Directed differentiation of human pluripotent cells to ureteric bud kidney progenitor-like cells[J].Nature Cell Biology, 2013, 15(12):1507-1515.
[14] Geurts M H, van der Vaart J, Beumer J, et al.The organoid platform:Promises and challenges as tools in the fight against COVID-19[J].Stem Cell Reports, 2021, 16(3):412-418.
[15] Birey F, Andersen J, Makinson C D, et al.Assembly of functionally integrated human forebrain spheroids[J].Nature, 2017, 545(7652):54-59.
[16] Wang H S.Modeling neurological diseases with human brain organoids[J].Frontiers in Synaptic Neuroscience, 2018, 10:15.
[17] 甘绍平,余涌.应用伦理学教程[M].2版.北京:企业管理出版社, 2017:217.
[18] Wasserman D, Adrienne A, Jeffrey B, et al.Cognitive disability and moral status[J/OL].(2017-08-11)[2022-01-13].https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/cognitive-disability/.
[19] Sawai T, Sakaguchi H, Thomas E, et al.The ethics of cerebral organoid research:Being conscious of consciousness[J].Stem Cell Reports, 2019, 13(3):440-447.
[20] Lavazza A, Massimini M.Cerebral organoids:Ethical issues and consciousness assessment[J].Journal of Medical Ethics, 2018, 44(9):606-610.
[21] Shepherd J.Ethical (and epistemological) issues regarding consciousness in cerebral organoids[J].Journal of Medical Ethics, 2018, 44(9):611-612.
[22] Boers S N, van Delden J J M, Bredenoord A L.Organoids as hybrids:Ethical implications for the exchange of human tissues[J].Journal of Medical Ethics, 2019, 45(2):131-139.
[23] Tooley M.Abortion and infanticide[J].Philosophy & Public Affairs, 1972, 2(1):37-65.
[24] Munsie M, Hyun I, Sugarman J.Ethical issues in human organoid and gastruloid research[J].Development, 2017, 144(6):942-945.
[25] Mansour A A, Gonçalves J T, Bloyd C W, et al.An in vivo model of functional and vascularized human brain organoids[J].Nature Biotechnology, 2018, 36(5):432-441.
[26] Boers S N, Bredenoord A L.Consent for governance in the ethical use of organoids[J].Nature Cell Biology, 2018, 20(6):642-645.
[27] 乐晶晶,周学迅,姚海嵩,等.生物样本活库发展现状及伦理问题探讨[J].中国科学:生命科学, 2020, 50(12):1464-1474.
[28] Chakradhar S.New company aims to broaden researchers' access to organoids[J].Nature Medicine, 2016, 22(4):338.
[29] 雷瑞鹏,邱仁宗.身体概念的生命伦理学分析[J].医学与哲学, 2020, 41(18):1-6.
[30] Svenaeus F.The lived body and personal identity:The ontology of exiled body parts[M]//Malmqvist E, Zeiler K.Bodily exchanges, bioethics and border crossing.London and New York:Routledge, 2015.
[31] 马琛婧,杨媛,张冰琳,等.类器官的研究现状及应用前景[J].昆明医科大学学报, 2019, 40(6):1-5.
2022, Vol. 40 
