人卵买卖问题引生了诸多乱象及伦理与法律争议。分析了卵买卖的乱象，总结了理论界支持和反对人卵买卖的两种现有观点；从人卵买卖违背人类辅助生殖技术应用初衷、会带来一系列社会问题以及会引发健康风险3个维度指出了人卵买卖的伦理本质；通过介绍域外人卵买卖规制的2种基本模式，指出了我国人卵买卖伦理治理与法律规制的不足；从强化生命伦理与健康教育、提升现行立法效力位阶、制定人卵管理专门法以及强化刑事立法等方面分别提出了完善我国人卵买卖伦理治理与法律规制的路径。
The issue of human egg trading has caused many chaos and ethical and legal disputes. Starting from the analysis of the chaos of human egg trading, this paper points out two existing views in the theoretical community that support and oppose human egg trading. It analyzes the ethical essence of human egg trading from three dimensions: the violation of the original intention of human assisted reproductive technology application, the series of social problems it will bring, and the health risks it will cause. It introduces two basic models of regulation for human egg trading outside the domain, and points out the shortcomings of ethical governance and legal regulation for human egg trading in China, We have proposed ways to improve the ethical governance and legal regulation of human egg trading in China from the perspectives of strengthening bioethics and health education, enhancing the effectiveness of current legislation, formulating specialized laws on human egg management, and strengthening criminal legislation.
[1] 姬妍,杨芳,潘荣华.人类辅助生殖中的卵子分享模式研究[J].南京医科大学学报(社会科学版), 2014, 14(1):11-15.
[2] 黄筱,毛一竹,帅才.触目惊心"取卵黑手"伸向女大学生[J].经济参考报, 2021-02-24(A05).
[3] 国熙.论地下商业冻、捐卵行为中的卵子流动[J].浙江学刊, 2020(6):115-123.
[4] Haoulia N. The venality of human body parts and produc-tions in French law and common law[J]. International Jour-nal of Bioethics, 2012, 2(1):67-86.
[5] Wilkinson S. Bodies for sale:Ethics and exploitation in the human body trade[M]. London:Routledge, 2003:108.
[6] 张波.捐赠卵子的研究进展[J].医学文选, 2002(5):704-706.
[7] 周燕,蒋其星.非医学原因生育力保存的伦理与法律分析[J].人权法学, 2023, 2(2):15-28.
[8] 杨硕,石文娣,徐策,等.辅助生殖技术中卵子捐献及交易的伦理问题[J].医学与哲学(A), 2013, 34(3):32-35.
[9] 张书增.非法买卖卵子问题成因与规制建议[J].郑州轻工业学院学报(社会科学版), 2015, 16(5):46-53.
[10] 林敏.试析组织精子卵子买卖行为的刑法规制问题[J].医学与法学, 2018, 10(6):31-36.
[11] [德]黑格尔.法哲学原理[M].杨东柱,尹建军,王哲,译,北京:北京出版社, 2007:76.
[12] 姬妍,杨芳.捐赠卵子所引发的社会伦理法律问题阐微[J].医学与法学, 2015, 7(5):11-14.
[13] 刘长秋.冻卵:法律应采取怎样的立场与对策[J].探索与争鸣, 2016(11):88-92.
[14] 冯士军,蓝风.卵子黑市盯上青春女孩:挣钱"捷径"风险重重[J].妇女生活, 2013(2):4-6.
[15] 孙梅,陈子江.卵巢过度刺激综合征[J].实用妇产科杂志, 2008, 24(8):462-464.
[16] Robertson, J A. Compensation and egg donation for re-search[J]. Fertility&Sterility, 2006, 86(6):1573-1575.
[17] Kenney N J, Mcgowan M L. Looking back:egg donors'retrospective evaluations of their motivations, expecta-tions, and experiences during their first donation cycle[J]. Fertility&Sterility, 2010, 93(2):455-466.
[18] Krawiec K D. Markets, morals, and limits in the ex-change of human eggs[J]. The Georgetown Journal of Law&Public Policy, 2015, 13:349-365.
[19] 朱琳.最新法国刑法典[M].北京:法律出版社, 2016:258.
[20] 杨芳.意大利《医学辅助生殖法》研究[J].东方法学, 2015(5):138-147.
[21] 孙贇,黄国宁,孙海翔,等.卵子捐赠与供/受卵相关问题的中国专家共识[J].生殖医学杂志, 2018, 27(10):932-939.
[22] 朱琳.我国高校生生命伦理与健康教育的现状与发展——评《大学生生命伦理与健康教育》[J].中国高校科技, 2021(7):101-102.
[23] 起底卖卵黑市:专攻女大学生,颜值学历成卖点,不打麻药穿刺下身[EB/OL].(2023-01-15)[2023-04-25]. http://news.sohu.com/a/630203513_121144268.
[24] 刘长秋.生命法学理论梳理与重构[M].北京:中国政法大学出版社, 2015:257.
[25] 刘长秋,周苏汇.我国生命健康治理法治化建设存在的问题及其对策[J].四川警察学院学报, 2022, 34(4):1-9.
[26] 刘长秋.论我国立法规制代孕的价值及其方向[J].南通大学学报(社会科学版), 2021, 37(3):100-109.
[27] 杨坤鑫.冷冻胚胎的民法和刑法规制[J].山西省政法管理干部学院学报, 2022, 35(4):72-75.
